Infernal Ramblings
A Malaysian Perspective on Politics, Society and Economics

Malaysia Boleh?

Written by johnleemk on 10:54:07 am Jun 2, 2005.
Categories:

Malaysia Boleh (literally, Malaysia Can) is the unofficial national motto of Malaysia. Ironically, it seems some people have taken this slogan a bit too seriously. I know of one lawyer who describes the situation in Malaysia as anarchy. Some would say that's too extreme, but is it?

While most of the opposition enjoys harping on issues like the laws BN pushed into existence to curtail royal privileges: oh no! See how UMNO and the Malays are destroying the existence of law and order by actually allowing the prosecution of royalty! Simply unacceptable!

Others point to the arrest and rough treatment Anwar endured, noting that this lack of due process and appropriate protection while being held in a lock-up indicate that even the police are now breaking the law. True, perhaps, but can the man on the street relate to Anwar? Anwar's just an ex-UMNOputra. No need to glorify him. If it were Mahathir in his place, most of these armchair politicians would be gloating, but as anyone knows, Anwar's the other side of the coin with Mahathir on the head.

Instead, let's look at a simple example of lawlessness: illegal parking. At the condominiums just outside my housing estate, people parking on both sides of the street reduce it to a one-lane road. This isn't just people furtively hiding from law enforcement either; they're doing it right in front of the guardhouse! Of course, the average Malaysian sees nothing wrong with this; people do the same thing at 1 Utama every weekend. But this can result in serious consequences. Resulting traffic jams and bottlenecks can lead to the loss of thousands of ringgit in terms of man-hours. In Singapore (or almost any other country claiming to be developed, for that matter), you'd be hit with summons like hell.

Naturally, anarchy also directly leads to vigilante justice. There have been many reported cases of people taking the law into their own hands; for example, in two separate incidents, thieves tried to rob two different cars. The frightened drivers beat the thieves to death with their steering wheel locks. And who can blame them? After reading about the man who had his thumb cut off (so it could activate the fingerprint-based ignition security system) or the thieves who knifed to death resisting victims, it's a surprise there are still a few people willing to let the police handle things.

Speaking of the police, remember that case recently? Yes, the one where police unwittingly freed 40+ criminals? In any other country, heads would have rolled within seconds of the escape's discovery. In Malaysia, the police officers apologise and are back on the job.

Perhaps the case of a particular Sultan's palace exemplifies all this: last year, the metal spikes on top of the palace's fencing were stolen. To date, the robbers have not been caught. Malaysia Boleh!


If you'd like to keep informed about updates to the site, consider subscribing to our web feed:

Infernal Ramblings is a Malaysian website focusing on current events and sociopolitical issues. Its articles run the gamut from economics to society to education.

Infernal Ramblings is run by John Lee. For more, see the About section. If you have any questions or comments, do drop him a line.


Comments

Thoughts? Comments? Discuss this and other ramblings at the forums.
(Alternatively, contact the author privately.)

Related comments from forum thread "Anwar Ibrahim - Potential PM or Plain Loser?":
johnleemk
Infernally Rambling Thoughtless Mind
Head Administrator
Posts: 949
IP Logged

Posted at 12:47:57 pm Jul 15, 2005
What do you think of Anwar? Is he a great man who got the boot for revolting against Mahathir, or is he just a loser who turned against UMNO only because he was no longer on the gravy train of juicy contracts?

(A longer critique of Anwar is available below, and a general criticism of the opposition is also available in this forum.)
Last five replies (17 comments not shown):
johnleemk
Infernally Rambling Thoughtless Mind
Head Administrator
Posts: 949
IP Logged
Posted at 10:47:02 am Sep 7, 2005
But Anwar was not only convicted by a court for corruption
I think that's hardly a fair assessment, even though I'm no fan of Anwar. The judicial system in Malaysia is under heavy influence from the executive branch. Nevertheless, I think there's more than enough anecdotal evidence that both Anwar and Mahathir were up to their neck in corruption.
johnleemk
Infernally Rambling Thoughtless Mind
Head Administrator
Posts: 949
IP Logged
Posted at 1:01:43 pm Sep 28, 2005
Malaysia Today, a generally pro-Anwar news site, has just published this:
http://www.malaysia-today.net/Blog-e/2005/09/perils-of-pro-malay-policies.htm

And it says...

Not long after Dr. Mahathir's protégé, Anwar Ibrahim, had replaced Mr. Daim as finance minister in 1991, he too was mired in controversy. Mr. Anwar was alleged to have practiced patronage, not to enrich himself, but to develop his power base in UMNO by creating his own breed of politicians-cum-businessmen to accelerate his rapid ascent up the party hierarchy. The use of money in UMNO elections subsequently intensified, creating what Dr. Mahathir later called a "culture of greed."

Although Dr. Mahathir and Messrs. Anwar and Daim all exercised control over the distribution of government concessions, the different reasons why they selectively patronized businessmen had a significant bearing on corporate Malaysia. Since Mr. Anwar's allies were politicians who had ventured into business principally to fund their political activities, their style of business was less productive, with many of them showing little capacity to build on their concessions. No Malay businessman linked to Mr. Anwar emerged as a major corporate figure by 1998, when he was sacked as deputy prime minister.

More proof Anwar is incapable of being trusted to lead our country.
johnleemk
Infernally Rambling Thoughtless Mind
Head Administrator
Posts: 949
IP Logged
Posted at 5:58:17 am Dec 12, 2005
Interesting letter in today's Malaysiakini.
cyrix
Member
Posts: 5
IP Logged
Posted at 12:02:26 am Dec 14, 2005
Quoted from: rakyat
Don't be clouded by the character assassination, what is impt is not the personality or sexual preference but his vision and where he plans to steer the country. Yes, many thing said bout AI might b true but we r only using him to break the hegemony & not 2 b our role model or father figure.

I agree with rakyat on this. It's all very nice to romanticise about politics and hope for the emergence of a noble political saviour to appear, but until that happens, one must confront the unpleasent reality that we face and work with what we have. Since Anwar, due more to his bad luck more than his convictions and principles, is now pushed into forming the Malay-based multiracial PKR to take on BN/UMNO, and he has promised a more civil and fairer society, why shouldn't we give him a chance to do so? What have we got to lose? Like what rakyat said, many people support Anwar not because we think he's a great role model or anything, its solely because, like it or not(in my case, NOT), he's the dude with the best potential to break BN's hegemony in M'sian politics. If he does get into power, and he breaks every promise he made, so what? Is that so different from what BN's doing right now? We could then just vote in BN in the next general elections.

It has already 48 years since we've gained Independence. In that space, how many prominent Malay leaders have snubbed UMNO and joined or formed multiracial parties? Check out this great article written by Dr Chandra Muzaffar on Malay-based political parties through the ages herehttp://www.aliran.com/high9912a.htm for more info.

In the hisory of Malaysian politics, there have only been 3 Malay leaders that were un-UMNO:

1. Dato Onn Jaafar - Independence for Malaya Party, Parti Negara
2. Dr Syed Husin Ali - Parti Rakyat Malaysia (PRM)
3. Abdul Aziz Ishak - National Convention Party (NCP)

Two more have almost no credibility and did so not because of their convictions, but solely with the aim of regaining lost power after failed leadership challenges:

1. Anwar Ibrahim - PKR
2. Tengku Razaleigh Hamzah - Semangat 46

With this track record after almost half a century, I think you'll be quite hard press to get a political saviour anytime soon in the near future.
NightHawk
Member
Posts: 187
IP Logged
Posted at 4:27:36 am Feb 21, 2006
whos cryix?


Latest:
Palin: A Politician of the People?
Popular:
Ending the Malaysian Culture Wars

Most Recently Read

  1. The Flawed Argument Against Welfare
  2. Pedra Branca is Useless
  3. Do People Take Everything I Say Seriously?
  4. Ending the Malaysian Culture Wars
  5. The Death of Malaysia
  6. Abdullah's Resignation: Pakatan's Ploy for Power?
  7. The Hypocritical Opposition
  8. Global Warming, True or False, Has No Bearing on the Environmental Question
  9. Why Hillary Clinton?
  10. The War Drums Beat for Iran
Latest active forum topics
Quoth the webserver...
He knows nothing; and he thinks he knows everything. That points clearly to a political career.
— George Bernard Shaw
Poll
Sorry, only registered users may vote. Please register or login.

There are currently no polls running.