Infernal Ramblings
A Malaysian Perspective on Politics, Society and Economics

Malaysian Apartheid

Written by johnleemk on 1:07:32 am May 9, 2007.
Categories: ,

I don't understand how people can so easily deny the apartheid that is in Malaysia. I mean, the Never Ending Policy — er, I mean, the New Economic Policy — is one thing, but the blatant ketuanan Melayu is a whole different kettle of fish.

After all, the fundamental premise of one is equality and parity between different communities. The fundamental premise of the other is inequality between the communities and the supremacism of one race.

Things would not be so bad if the NEP had been implemented properly, and its ideals of equality done justice. But instead it has become a tool of Malay supremacists and government cronies to enrich themselves, at the expense of all Malaysians, including the Malays.

Making matters worse, the government is beginning to shed its pretence of equality and justice. Not too long ago, they even announced they would literally discriminate according to skin colour in the employment market, forcing advertising agencies not to hire Pan-Asian models!

Even the blatant injustice of some economic policies is becoming more and more apparent. It is now almost impossible to justify this sham of a New Economic Policy when all its initiatives are blatantly meant to enrich one race at the expense of others.

Just look at the recent announcement that two banks would now only do business with law firms where the majority partner is a Bumiputra. How can you call this anything other than apartheid?

It's one thing to, say, give preference to Bumiputra-owned firms when all other things are equal. It's one thing to give priority to the Bumiputra poor when distributing welfare cheques.

It's a whole different thing to announce you will be only doing business with Bumiputra-owned firms, end of story. That's apartheid, and there's no other word for it.

Malaysians have to realise this — have to realise that the fruits of this government we have elected are apartheid and injustice, not equality and fraternity. There are ten reasons not to vote for this regime — and though apartheid is just one of them, it sticks out like a sore thumb.

Most countries around the world have abandoned such blatantly discriminatory and unjust policies. Even South Africa, despite the subjugation of the blacks by the whites for so long, has resisted attempts to unfairly discriminate against the whites in uplifting the black communities.

Why should our country be any different? We have the vote — and let's use it to show that although apartheid may be a policy of the Malaysian government, it is not a policy of the Malaysian people.


If you'd like to keep informed about updates to the site, consider subscribing to our web feed:

Infernal Ramblings is a Malaysian website focusing on current events and sociopolitical issues. Its articles run the gamut from economics to society to education.

Infernal Ramblings is run by John Lee. For more, see the About section. If you have any questions or comments, do drop him a line.


Comments

Thoughts? Comments? Discuss this and other ramblings at the forums.
(Alternatively, contact the author privately.)

Related comments from forum thread "RE: Pan-Asian Models and the Road to Apartheid":
kufar
Member
Posts: 23
IP Logged

Posted at 2:23:37 am Feb 24, 2007
johnleemk wrote at:
http://www.infernalramblings.com/articles/Malaysian_Socio-Politics/134/


Whoever is to blame, I think this is really a slap in the face of Pan-Asian Malaysians, and the Malaysian public as a whole.

Are not Malaysians Asians too? Obviously, you are ranting nonsense and do not know the root cause of the ban is not skin colour (as Malaysia does not discriminate by skin colour) but rather religion. Tudungless women are not allowed and a Chinese man must wear Baju Melayu and Songkok, while a Chinese woman must wear Baju Kurung and Tudung. No sexy Malaysian is allowed in accordance to Islam Hadhari.


This is a policy of blatant discrimination against people on the grounds of their looks, plain and simple.

How do you know it is about looks of people? Did the government tell you they discriminate by skin colour? Or you are writing a spin like self-proclaimed pro-blogger Jeff Ooi, which got him ultimated sued by NSTP? The special status of the Melayu is hardly racial as a Melayu could be any Muslim (or Muslimah) regardless of skin colour. A yellow-skin Chinese Muslimah is also legally an ethnic Melayu.


At least in the past, our government was content to be quiet in its chauvinist policies.

What is wrong with chauvinist policies? Cultural chauvinism is hardly racism. UMNO is the most multi-racial party with ethnic Melayu of various skin colour, such as Yellow-skin, Brown-skin, Black-skin and White-skin. Any Pan-Asian model must be dressed either as a Muslim or Muslimah. This could give job oppurtunities to Chinese Muslimah instead of non Muslim women.


Even if skin colour was a factor, they wouldn't shout it in your face.

Skin colour was never a factor for 49-years of Malaysian history as a Melayu is hardly a race in the sense of a Chinese, as Melayu has various ancestry, Chinese-looking Malays (such as Pak Lah's late wife, Endon) or Pakistani looking Malays (such as Tun Dr Mahathir). Only those who love to propaganda opposition propaganda would claim Malaysia is a "racist" state and call concept of Ketuanan Melayu as racist, when it is not but Muslim supremacy.


After all, you don't have to be brown to get a 7% discount on your new luxury condominium or to get discounted allocations of new initial public offerings — you just have to be a "Bumiputra", which can be easily accomplished with conversion to Islam.

Are you suffering from mental illness? You keep insisting Malaysians have to be brown-skin to enjoy a 7% discount on housing! I am a Chinese convert to Islam and look very Chinese, and am proudly an ex-MCA member who now is an UMNO member. Yes, yellow-skin Chinese-looking Malaysians can join UMNO if they masuk Melayu (convert to Islam). I support ban on Pan-Asian models as most of them are tudungless and this will be against UMNO policy of Islam Hadhari.


Now, on the other hand, even theoretically first-class citizens — the Bumiputra — may be out of a job if the government doesn't deem them Malaysian-looking enough!

Only according to *you* will the Bumiputra be jobless! Why do we need tudungless Pan-Asian models to be advertised in the newspapers and TV? To be a citizen of Malaysia is to be Malay (which includes not only those who are ancestrally Malays but also Chinese Muslims and Indian Muslims who are naturalised Malays). Unconverted Chinese like yourself John Lee Ming Kuan should be deported to Singapore and stripped of your Malaysian nationality. Malaysia is for the adherents of Islam only.


I'm not sure about you, but I call the blatant denial of employment to a particular class of people on grounds of physical appearance apartheid.

You are guilty of misusing words. The word "apartheid" refers to organised racism - racial discrimination. There is absolutely *no* racism in Malaysia as concept of Melayu as in "Ketuanan Melayu" refers to any adherent of Islam irrespective of race. According to the 1957 Federal Constitution and 1946 UMNO Party Constitution, every Muslim and Muslimah regardless of skin colour or ancestry is considered a Melayu.

So, Palestinians, Iraqis, Afgans and Somali (though ethnically Arab) are also Melayu in the same way Chinese Muslims are Melayu.

Last five replies (3 comments not shown):
johnleemk
Infernally Rambling Thoughtless Mind
Head Administrator
Posts: 949
IP Logged
Posted at 12:14:27 am Jun 12, 2007
Actually as I recall it, the Straits Chinese/Peranakan/Baba/whatever you call them have never been fully accorded their due. Even in the 1920s and 30s, they were revolted by being treated the same as any other recent Chinese migrant - even though the latter probably deserved second-class treatment, why should those who could trace their roots back be treated the same? In the 1940s, there was even a secessionist movement in Penang because the Straits Chinese thought they were not treated fairly.
Michael Chick
Member
Posts: 7
IP Logged
Posted at 8:47:41 am Jun 19, 2007
And to that effect, the Baba's are supposed to be rightfully restored as Bumiputeras. If you read my above post, even the Indians should be accorded Bumiputera status, coz they were here 2,000yrs ago at Lembah Bujang, and converted all the Malays to Hindus. Where's the fairness? And yet, the recent Chitti's (in comparison) are Bumiputera.

Heck!!! Even an Indonesian who arrives in a boat tomorrow can claim to be a Bumiputera. What insignificant definition is Bumiputera now?
Mujaheed
Member
Posts: 1
IP Logged
Posted at 12:03:16 am Apr 13, 2008
[Potentially offensive/illegal and nonsensically incoherent post removed by admin]
tigasuku
Member
Posts: 1
IP Logged
Posted at 7:42:24 am Apr 20, 2008
Michael Chick,

I really like your long article Posted at 11:26:00 am Jun 11, 2007. A little bit too late to discover this subject but I hope other Malaysians read it too. Why are we bickering about Malay, Chinese, Indians, Bumiputra bla..bla..bla when maybe tomorrow the world will come to an end? Or one of us will die unexpectedly. We should just enjoy our life when we still can. For those who don't want to share the living space with others or other races, then they should live in a cave.

By a brown color Malay.

darkgold
Member
Posts: 1
IP Logged
Posted at 12:10:25 pm Apr 23, 2008
Funny this...how many mixed raced people are actually replying? Not that many!

I've read your responses and frankly I don't see why you would give a darn about mine since I happen to be a 'dumb and confused' monrel but I'll say it anyway.

Mixed race - the term doesn't apply just to half whites. It applies to a mixtures of cultures be they black brown or yellow. I have no idea whether my future kids who might be part African/Middle Eastern/Indian will face this ban-under my household they better look good because hey, that's part of being a Mongrel. That said what really tees me off is the amount of people who are proudly proclaiming they are Malay just because they are Muslim. So what does that make the other Muslims all around the world? Are you going to dictate their race to them too? Or are they not 'Muslim' enough because they don't have a clue what Malay as and frankly would give a c**p?

You want Muslim models, go ahead. There are lots of Muslims who are mixed race-I'd say they set an even more better example of Islam because Islam is not about 'sticking to your own kind'. If I saw a part Trinidadian, part Maldivian Muslim model on Malaysian billboards, I would say he/she is just as Islamic as as a thousand tudungs and skullcaps. Islam is not just about dress. What about looking after the environment and not gossiping in the Surau or wolf whistling at other women? You see signs crossing out mini skirts and bare hair-what about a sign that bans Mat Rempit and snatch thieves?

I would never tick the box that autiomatically denomenates me to Malay-it would only negate my Chinese and Indonesian race. And before you start going on about how Malays are a mix of this and that, sure they are, but what culture do they follow? I'm not into having babies by the time I'm 22 (past that already) nor leaving it all to 'riski' or 'tiada apo'. Neither would I go near that Bumputera benefical system with a bargepole. My family are Malay, Chinese and Indonesian and adopted ones are Indian. If they're not entitled to this bumiputera system, why the hell should I be? Most likely my children's dad will not Malay-what will they be entitled to when they want to buy a house because my race as 'only the mum' means diddles**t (apart from the fact that I don't call myself Malay anyway)

So for all you purists-stop thinking you have a claim on us. You don't speak for us mixed raced Malaysians-that is our job. We don't care about your racial spats. We don't care about your pure 'pride' because like it or not it's ours too. Call it selfish but we prefer not to make your problems ours because you disowned from the very day we were born and implemented such stupid rules such as banning our united blood.






Latest:
Personality Cults Come With the Territory
Popular:
Personality Cults Come With the Territory

Most Recently Read

  1. The Flawed Argument Against Welfare
  2. Absolute vs Comparative Advantage
  3. Pros and Cons of Unionisation
  4. Malaysia, A Statist Economy
  5. In Defence of McDonaldisation
  6. Incest and the Law
  7. How Do You Define Democracy?
  8. Taking A Stand Against Defamation and For Freedom of Speech
  9. My Boss, Nathaniel Tan, Martyred by the Special Branch
  10. Analysing the Beatles' Success
Latest active forum topics
Quoth the webserver...
The inherent vice of capitalism is the unequal sharing of blessings; the inherent virtue of socialism is the equal sharing of misery.
— Winston Churchill
Poll
Sorry, only registered users may vote. Please register or login.

There are currently no polls running.