Malaysia Has No Shortcuts to Success
Written by johnleemk on 5:02:20 am Apr 20, 2007.
Categories: Malaysian Society
After Where is Malaysia on the World Stage?, Say Lee responds:
Actually, traditionally USA has been quite parochial in outlook, despite their "forays" into Korea and Vietnam. And her geopolitical awareness and international worldview are dictated by keeping tab on countries that are of strategic importance to them, either in military terms or in terms of natural resources. So the slant in international news coverage domestically has contributed to the ignorance of a large portion of her citizenry as regards occurrences beyond her shore.
The Internet has helped ameliorated this situation somewhat but Malaysia still ranks behind Singapore, Vietnam, Philippines, Thailand, and even Indonesia as far as knowing a country in SE Asia is concerned.
To that extent, pegging whether Malaysia is a global player known on the world's stage to the knowledge of the US populace on Malaysia may perhaps be unfair. But I have no reason to think that we will be more widely known in the EU circle, our former status as a British colony notwithstanding, except for the prowess of our sportsmen/women in Badminton and Squash, both games being much less popular in US.
Whatever it is, your entreaty to focus on the peopleware is right on the mark, provided we can shed our edifice mentality in time and in earnest.
It is indisputably true that most Americans are truly ignorant of what goes on outside their country.
But at the same time, there are many educated and knowledgeable Americans. They are not many, but they do keep tabs on things that go beyond the headlines on CNN.
Many of these people, for example, will be able to talk with you about the problem of Darfur, or about the nascent democratic movement in China. They are well-versed in geopolitics.
Down the line, there are those who can't claim to be so well-acquainted with issues of global importance, but still do know more than the average American.
Both of these two groups can somehow have a rough idea of what and where Singapore is. But most, if not all of them have no idea of what or where Malaysia is.
As noted, it's difficult to argue that the situation is any better in Europe, considering our circumstances and lack of substantial achievements. Singapore is known as a world-class tourist destination, hub for biomedicine, a dynamic capitalist state, and an authoritarian nanny state.
Malaysia can't lay claim to a single one of these titles. We can't even oppress our people properly enough for the world to sit up and take notice.
Our sporting prowess in badminton and squash is indeed something to be proud of — and interestingly, we haven't had to build any megaprojects like a new sports complex in England to nurture these athletes. All we had to do was focus on developing their talents the oldfashioned way.
That's the problem with Malaysia — we would rather settle for easy oil money and use it to find false shortcuts to success. If we want to make it in the world, there really is no substitute for human resource development.
Here are the most popular articles in Malaysian Society:
If you'd like to keep informed about updates to the site, consider subscribing to our web feed:
Infernal Ramblings is a Malaysian website focusing on current events and sociopolitical issues. Its articles run the gamut from economics to society to education.
Infernal Ramblings is run by John Lee. For more, see the About section. If you have any questions or comments, do drop him a line.
Comments
Thoughts? Comments? Discuss this and other ramblings at the forums.
(Alternatively, contact the author privately.)
| Related comments from forum thread "Where is Malaysia on the world stage?": | |
|---|---|
|
afirstmed
Member Posts: 9 IP Logged | Posted at 4:24:56 am Apr 15, 2007
In respond to the above titled post: Obviously you haven't been travelling much, have you? In my college, the Malaysians aren't exactly the wealthiest group of students around. But when it comes to travelling rights, our Malaysian passport brings us visa free to most European countries (especially the Schengen nations). Contrast that with many of our African and Middle Eastern friends who need visas for practically every country they would like to visit. So...you might be thinking big, world stage. But quiet diplomacy, that's where our strategy lies. And I like it. |
| Last five replies (0 comments not shown): | |
|
johnleemk
Infernally Rambling Thoughtless Mind Head Administrator Posts: 948 IP Logged | Posted at 6:18:36 am Apr 15, 2007
Sorry I haven't replied to your emails; been very busy (and tired) lately. That aside, I honestly don't see the relevance of your comment to the article in question. You seem to be rambling about tourist visas when the point of the article is:
You might be insinuating that we can make Malaysia well-known by having a lot of Malaysian tourists visit other countries. But this seems rather impractical, and I can't really think of any countries who have become known because of their citizens' propensity for visiting other countries. |
|
afirstmed
Member Posts: 9 IP Logged | Posted at 10:56:29 am Apr 15, 2007
Apologies if my message wasn't phrased the way I wanted it to be. My example of tourist visas should not be seen the way you have interpreted it. You should be aware that countries whose citizens can enter other countries without visas have a good diplomatic presence wherever they are. So, 'quiet diplomacy' isn't having Malaysian hordes trawl the world, but having our foreign service do a good job when they represent our country abroad. Hence, in my opinion, our country does have a strong presence on the world stage, but not at a level where ordinary redneck hicks from the US Midwest know where our country is on the world map. But this presence shows itself in more subtle ways, as per the example I quoted above. p.s. I'd like to share with you a story which never fails to make me feel proud to be a Malaysian. A few years back, I was on a deserted desert road in a Middle Eastern country. The car I was travelling in then came across a military checkpoint and the M-16 toting soldier wanted to see my passport. I felt panicky as I left my passport in the hotel. The driver of the car then spoke in Arabic to the soldier saying that I was from Malaysia. The soldier suddenly broke into a huge grin and waved me through. Just like that. Fascinating stuff. |
|
johnleemk
Infernally Rambling Thoughtless Mind Head Administrator Posts: 948 IP Logged | Posted at 1:46:59 pm Apr 15, 2007
But this presence shows itself in more subtle ways, as per the example I quoted above. It seems we are talking about different things then. Most Malaysians do seem to think that we are known among "US rednecks", but even the well-informed Americans don't seem to know what or where Malaysia is. For most Malaysians, being known to the average bloke from other countries is what constitutes being on the world stage, and from this definition, I'd say we aren't well-known at all. It's very interesting, as you note, to see that we are so known in the Middle East. But even if we are well-known, it's not an excuse to promote building megaprojects at the expense of actual development in terms of quality of life and advancement opportunities for individual citizens. |
