Infernal Ramblings
A Malaysian Perspective on Politics, Society and Economics

Undeniable Income Inequality

Written by johnleemk on 9:21:05 am Jul 13, 2007.
Categories: ,

Last night, I went to queue up for tickets to a showing of Transformers. (For those who realise I've mentioned the movie quite a bit lately, I can't help it — my sister made us watch it again.)

Normally, when the queue is extraordinarily long, I have someone to talk to so I don't pay attention to my surroundings, but last night, I looked around and listened...and realised a disproportionate amount of those around me were Chinese. You could easily be forgiven for thinking you were in China, considering that most of them were speaking some Chinese dialect.

Now, there are a number of possible reasons for the apparent absence of other Malaysian communities in the queue to buy tickets to a movie.

For instance, you could argue that the Malays and Indians have different preferences — that they spend their money on other things. However, considering that both are generally enjoined by their religions from certain enjoyments — the Muslims cannot drink or eat pork, and the Hindus cannot eat beef — it is far more likely that they would be slightly overrepresented, since they have less avenues for entertainment.

You might argue that they prefer to watch movies on DVD instead. There's a whole cornucopia of excuses you could concoct for why they are so hugely underrepresented.

However, the simplest answer is staring us in the face — they cannot afford to watch movies in the cinema. The Malays and Indians are just too poor, while the Chinese are (as a general rule) the bulk of the middle class.

If you just pay attention to our society and observe, these things are very clear. The cinema is actually one of the better places to examine these issues — racial issues can crop up quite a bit.

Yet, so many people are blind to these obvious problems. This is why I am so infuriated whenever a debate on race in Malaysia crops up — there are extremists on both sides who claim to be for equality but demand equality only when it benefits them.

The fact is, you cannot go on with almost half of Malaysian citizens treated as second-class members of the Malaysian nation and denied the opportunity to serve in our government.

Equally, you cannot go on with over half of all Malaysian citizens denied freedom from poverty and denied equality of economic opportunity.

For eons, our society has been dominated by paradigms which tie race to socioeconomic function. But if you look around enough, if you think enough, you will realise that these paradigms cannot hope to last. What our society needs is nothing more than a commitment to true equality of opportunity.


If you'd like to keep informed about updates to the site, consider subscribing to our web feed:

Infernal Ramblings is a Malaysian website focusing on current events and sociopolitical issues. Its articles run the gamut from economics to society to education.

Infernal Ramblings is run by John Lee. For more, see the About section. If you have any questions or comments, do drop him a line.


Comments

Thoughts? Comments? Discuss this and other ramblings at the forums.
(Alternatively, contact the author privately.)

Related comments from forum thread "The race factor":
johnleemk
Infernally Rambling Thoughtless Mind
Head Administrator
Posts: 948
IP Logged

Posted at 9:11:38 am Sep 1, 2005
In Malaysia, a lot of us seem d*** hung up about race. Whenever the fault of some people from another race is pointed out, the race being attacked takes the opportunity to generalise about the failures of the accusing race, and vice-versa. It's sheer insanity.

I have even seen some people argue that Malays and Chinese have both their strengths and weaknesses as races - not people! Apparently the theory that race affects capability is far from dead in Malaysia, and not just among the Chinese; some Malays use a similar variation of such an argument.

Until we stop being so uptight about race and on guard for any slurs against what we perceive to be our honour, forget about being united. All the multiracial parties and elimination of special rights can never have any effect unless the people themselves are willing to disabuse themselves of racial stereotypes and start seeing one another as people instead of Malay, Chinese or Indian.

Students from vernacular schools as young as nine years of age are taunting Indians for their skin colour (some in secondary school still have a phobia of them). Most Malays never have the opportunity to mix with Chinese and Indians due to vernacular schools. The solution? National service, a stop-gap measure ten years too late; integration should begin at seven, not seventeen!

These conditions breed the sort of racial divisions that were reflected in Parliament a few months ago when one MP took the trouble to complain about an advertisement showing a Malay youth being rude. Until we rid ourselves of this parasitic cancer, I am very pessimistic about Malaysia's future.

The first step to eliminating racial stereotyping and division is to integrate schools. But of course the d*** Chinese/Tamil chauvinists won't accept this, even if the Mandarin and Tamil language classes are readily available in most national primary schools!

Clearing this hurdle clears the way to many other things. A rakyat that is no longer divided will pay no heed to any number of keris-wavings. A rakyat united will call for a more even-handed affirmative action policy. A rakyat united will stop this f***ing bulls*** about race, and start talking about the nation.

Sounds farfetched? It is. I've given up hope on Malaysia. It's the old chicken-or-egg cycle; the government won't change till the rakyat changes, but the rakyat won't change till the government changes. Oh, well. KERANAMU MALAYSIA

(sung to the tune of "Malaysia Berjaya"

Malaysia, Malaysia, negara berpisah
Malaysia, Malaysia, hanyalah hargai bangsa
Sekolah vernakular membahagi rakyat selalu
Cina takut orang India
Sambil kaum Melayu katalah "balik China!"
Dengan perpisahan ketara antara semua bangsa
Malaysia tiadalah harapan, rakyatnya semua gila!
Last five replies (45 comments not shown):
charis14
Member
Posts: 1
IP Logged
Posted at 11:17:29 pm Jun 26, 2008
Both my wife and me do not know Mandarin. We have a national (Malay) school within walking distance from home. So we did the right thing - we sent 2 of our children to the national school. As they progressed along, we realised the poor state of teaching and discipline.
Our response - We sent our youngest child to a Chinese school though it meant fighting traffic jams and having to learn Mandarin together with them.
azrulazmie
Member
Posts: 1
IP Logged
Posted at 7:59:32 pm Jul 2, 2008
It has been many years after the independence and i wonder why shouldn't a country with abundance of Chinese and Indians does not offer Tamil and Chinese language in its national school. I think its pathetic.

Plus, I also think MRSM and the so-called Malay elite school are also agents of racial segregation.
johnleemk
Infernally Rambling Thoughtless Mind
Head Administrator
Posts: 948
IP Logged
Posted at 10:19:28 pm Jul 2, 2008
No doubt, Azrul. It's pretty ironic, actually. When you go to secondary school, all you get are reinforcements of negative Malay stereotypes because the brightest Malays have been shipped off to boarding schools.
AnnaLog
Member
Posts: 2
IP Logged
Posted at 10:59:06 am Jul 3, 2008
Big changes are hard to make, so start with a small one. Refuse to fill out the 'race' section of any and all forms. Suggest to your company that they do the same. One step, one foot in front of the other and eventually you will get there. Take a step. Refuse to fill it out. I refuse. The only race I'm in is the human race and Malaysia is rather far behind the pack at this point.

If race is not on the application form - it won't mean that the HR person will view Malay/Chinese/India/Other any differently when they walk through the door, but then, it's a start. Small, but a start. Make a start.
ChongSK38
Member
Posts: 1
IP Logged
Posted at 3:28:52 am Jul 12, 2008
"The first step to eliminating racial stereotyping and division is to integrate schools. But of course the d*** Chinese/Tamil chauvinists won't accept this, even if the Mandarin and Tamil language classes are readily available in most national primary schools! "

Hi Johnleemk, I'm new here, I saw you from Wikipedia.

Good to have someone discussing "Education in Malaysia", extremely important topic but maybe only a few in Malaysia are expert enough to discuss without later on getting angry and start calling each other "extremist"


Latest:
Unity That Matters: Reclaiming Our Non-Racial Past
Popular:
Why Anwar's Arrest Matters for Liberty and Justice

Most Recently Read

  1. How Do You Define Democracy?
  2. Conflating Head of Government and Head of State
  3. BERSIH Rally: A Waste of Our Taxes
  4. Pak Lah: To Resign or Not Resign
  5. Institutions, Not People, Make the Country
  6. The DAP and its weaknesses
  7. An Economic Solution for Slums?
  8. Ethnic Descent, Nationality and Race: What is a Malaysian?
  9. Should We Help the Unemployed?
  10. Pedra Branca is Useless
Google
Latest active forum topics
Quoth the webserver...
Which is the best government? That which teaches us to govern ourselves.
— Goethe
Poll
Sorry, only registered users may vote. Please register or login.

There are currently no polls running.